MCQIndia.comCBSE
CBSE
Class 9 · Mathematics

Chapter 9: Propositions and their Converses

Revision notes, worked problems, a question bank, assertion and reason questions and answers to the NCERT exercises. Tap a group to open it; opening one closes the others.

9.1Propositions and conversesIf X then Y, and its converse

Propositions

  • A proposition is a statement that is either true or false. “If X then Y” is also written “X implies Y” or “Y when X”.
  • The converse of “if X then Y” is “if Y then X”.
  • Statement: if two sides of a triangle are equal, the angles opposite are equal. Converse: if two angles are equal, the sides opposite are equal.

Is the converse always true?

ABCD∠B = ∠C
Converse of the isosceles-triangle theorem: draw AD ⟂ BC; ΔABD ≅ ΔACD (AAS), so AB = AC.
  • No. Proposition P: if it rains, the road is wet (true). Converse Q: if the road is wet, it has rained (false: a tanker may spill water).
  • Converse of the isosceles theorem is true: draw the altitude AD; ΔABD ≅ ΔACD by AAS (∠B = ∠C, ∠ADB = ∠ADC = 90°, AD common), so AB = AC.
  • So a proposition can be true with a true converse, true with a false converse, or even false with a false converse.
9.2Counterexamples and examplesShowing a statement is false

Counterexamples

  • A counterexample is a single case that makes a proposition false. One is enough.
  • Fermat claimed 2^(2ⁿ) + 1 is always prime (n = 0, 1, 2, 3 give 3, 5, 17, 257). Euler showed 2³² + 1 = 4294967297 = 641 × 6700417 is composite.
  • Multiples: “multiple of 6 ⇒ multiple of 3” is true (6k = 3 × 2k); the converse fails for 9.
  • Same area ⇒ congruent? False (a 6 × 4 and an 8 × 3 rectangle both have area 24). Congruent ⇒ same area is true.

Squares and factors

  • P: a perfect square has an odd number of factors. Q: a number with an odd number of factors is a perfect square. Both true.
  • Factors pair up (f, n/f); an odd count needs a repeated pair (f, f), so n = f² (this proves Q). A number has at most one such pair (f = √n), so a square has an odd count (this proves P).
9.3Pythagoras and its converseBaudhāyana–Pythagoras both ways

The converse is true

BCAYZXabcabXY = ?
Converse of the Baudhāyana–Pythagoras theorem: XY² = a² + b² = c², so XY = c and ΔABC ≅ ΔXYZ (SSS).
  • Theorem: if a triangle is right-angled, then a² + b² = c². Converse: if a² + b² = c², then the triangle is right-angled.
  • Proof: build a right triangle XYZ with YZ = a, XZ = b. Then XY² = a² + b² = c², so XY = c. ΔABC ≅ ΔXYZ by SSS, so ∠C = 90°.
  • Test: 8, 15, 17: 64 + 225 = 289, right-angled. 5, 6, 7: 25 + 36 ≠ 49, not right-angled.

Another way to say it

  • “If a number is a perfect square, then it has an odd number of factors” and “A number has an odd number of factors when it is a perfect square” mean the same.
  • When both a proposition and its converse are true we say X and Y are equivalent (each implies the other).
RefChecklistHow to test a proposition and its converse

Steps

  • Write P: “if X then Y”.
  • Write the converse Q: “if Y then X”.
  • For each, either give a proof or a counterexample.
  • Examples of both true: x = y ⇔ x³ = y³ (real numbers); n divisible by 60 ⇔ divisible by 5 and 12; both false: “every prime is odd” and its converse “every odd number is prime”.

Common slips

  • Believing the converse of a true statement must be true.
  • Trying to prove a statement with examples instead of a proof (examples never prove, counterexamples disprove).
  • Proving Q when asked for P (as in the factor-partner argument).
  • Forgetting conditions such as “positive integer”.